Sign the Save Organic Coffee petition

by JulieCraves on April 17, 2007

An article in Salon outlines a recent U.S. Department of Agriculture ruling which will require every farm in a cooperative to be inspected annually in order to receive organic certification. Previously, about 20% of the farms were inspected annually. The growers and management of the co-op made sure all farms, not just those being inspected, followed the rules.  Given the large number of small farmers in some co-ops and their often remote locations, this staggered inspection is the only practical way to certify these growers.

Since farms must pay inspectors, the added cost could prove to make organic certification too expensive for small farmers. Should this ruling really be enforced, it would surely drastically reduce the number of farms offering organic coffee (big plantations would be able to afford it). Stripping the added revenue brought in by organic certification would drive many small farmers out of the coffee business (the ruling covers all organic crops, by the way).  Hello land-clearing, pastures, drug crops, and other far less ecologically-friendly alternatives. For a bit more, a little backgrounder on organic coffee and why it’s important from Bloggle, and a deeper post at the Gristmill blog on how this ruling will impact farmers in the developing world. I’ve also written a series on coffee pests, pesticides, and organic certification.

This was an (apparently overzealous) administrative ruling in response to an appeal by a Mexican farmer who was denied certification. I’m not familiar with how binding these rulings are and how they are codified and enforced. But the coffee industry and consumers have started to mobilize.  And Nora Edison and Chris Neumann of Sweetwater Organic Coffee Roasters sent me a link to a petition to be sent to the USDA asking them to reconsider their policy change. They are seeking 10,000 signatures, so it can’t hurt to sign on:

Sign the “Save Organic Coffee” Petition.

Revised on November 14, 2019

Posted in Certifications,Organic coffee

Debbie April 18, 2007 at 11:39 am

I'm all for the petition, but the panic and outrage in the blogosphere may be a bit of an overreaction – much as this ruling is. Government entities have a way of making extreme, fear-based decisions, then toning them down when they see their effects (forcing their inspectors to travel to remote areas of Kenya to inspect a tiny farm,for example.)


BirdBarista April 18, 2007 at 12:25 pm

Debbie, I agree with you, which is why I did not post about this topic when it initially came to light, and didn't indicate it was critical for people to sign the petition, although I don't think it hurts. As I said, I don't know how these types of rulings get etched in stone, but when I read the actual ruling, tucked into a paragraph of several pages of other mundane administrative stuff, I was struck by how understated and trivial it appeared, anyway. We'll see how it all comes out…

BOTDA April 19, 2007 at 9:46 pm

Your site has won a Blog of the Day Award (BOTDA)

Award Code

Thank you,

famous quotes

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: